While the turkey is the centerpiece of the main meal, dessert is always part of the conversation. People hold back on a second helping of mashed potatoes to ensure a sweet ending. But, the most requested Thanksgiving pie does not feature a particular gourd. What slice is everyone eating this year?
Food trends continually evolve. Whether it is protein maxxing, smaller portions, or even globally influenced flavors, it can be hard to keep up with all the changes.
At the same time, many people love traditional, nostalgic food. From grandma’s infamous sweet potato casserole to the canned jellied cranberries, a holiday meal is incomplete without those items.
Dessert is always part of the celebratory meal. Pie is the common choice at Thanksgiving. While everyone thinks that pumpkin is the top choice, Goldbelly found that people are skipping that creamy, warm spicy slice. Maybe it is PSL overload. No matter the reason, another all-American choice is front and center on the table.
Goldbelly Says This Is the Most Requested Thanksgiving Pie
According to Goldbelly’s survey, apple pie is the top pick for Thanksgiving dessert. Their findings say that 33% of all Thanksgiving pie orders are apple, followed by 24% for pecan and 10% for pumpkin. Even though people think that pumpkin is a top choice, it is just a small fraction compared to apple and pecan.
While many people will happily peel apple after apple to fill that pie shell, others prefer to let the experts take the lead. Luckily, Goldbelly has some of the best apple pies in the nation, all of them shipped directly to people’s door.
The top selling apple pie is Elegant Farmer. The famous Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag is the top seller. Personally, the version with the sugar cookie crust is the optimum choice.
For people who prefer a sweeter option, the caramel version is a must order. But, this flavor is best served with a dollop of whipped cream or scoop of vanilla ice cream to cut through all the sweetness.
Goldbelly has a wide array of pie choices. From regional favorites to bakeries topping the best of lists, there is a pie to satisfy every craving.
And, if people cannot decide on just one option, there is always the iconic Piecaken. The beloved Zac Young mega dessert makes a big statement on the table. The Thanksgiving flavor combines all the favorite flavors into a single slice. If you have never tasted this dessert creation, it is a must buy.
This holiday season, follow the trend and serve the popular pie choice. Skip the pumpkin for apple. It might not keep the doctor away but it is a dessert that satisfies with every serving.




Leave a Reply